For a variety of reasons, many breweries don’t brew all of their beer where you think they do. Usually, it’s because they simply don’t have the capacity at their main brewery to meet demand, so they farm out some of their brewing to equally capable but much larger breweries. It’s called “contract brewing,” and it’s nothing unusual. In fact, without contract brewing, you’d be hard-pressed to find some of your favorite beers. Here are some of those beers.

Brooklyn Lager
Where you think it’s brewed: Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Where it’s brewed: F.X. Matt Brewery, Utica, NY
Many beer geeks do know this, but the brewery that’s open for tours in Brooklyn doesn’t brew most of the Brooklyn beer you drink. Space is at a premium in New York City, and there simply isn’t enough room for the bottling equipment to meet Brooklyn Brewery’s demand. Any Brooklyn beer sold at retail in a 12-ounce bottle is brewed in Utica. The brewery in Brooklyn does produce quite a bit of beer, though; the Brewmaster’s Reserve series, including Detonation, Blast!, Dark Matter, and the Shackmeister Ale served at Shake Shack, are all brewed there. And, the brewery in Williamsburg is currently in the midst of a multi-million dollar expansion to boost their capacity.

Fire Island Lighthouse Ale
Where you think it’s brewed: Fire Island, NY
Where it’s brewed: Relata Brewing Co., Saratoga Springs, NY
The dirty little secret: there is no brewery on Fire Island. While the concept of the brewery and the beer recipe was conceived at “The Shack” - a general store in Atlantique - all Fire Island beer is brewed upstate. That’s probably a good idea, because with the cost of real estate, the lack of motorized vehicular traffic, and cost to ship materials across the Great South Bay, their beer would be terribly expensive. Lighthouse Ale is contract brewed in the same place where all of the Mendocino, Coney Island, and He'brew lines of beers are brewed.

Sixpoint Sweet Action
Where you think it’s brewed: Red Hook, Brooklyn
Where it’s brewed: The Lion Brewery, Wilkes-Barre, PA
We mentioned this a few weeks ago, but Sixpoint’s huge rise to prominence has left them with their own supply and demand challenge at their brewery in Brooklyn. Some batches of a few of their most popular beers - Bengali Tiger, Sweet Action, Righteous Rye, and Brownstone - are now brewed at a much larger brewery in Pennsylvania that has a successful record of contract brewing. Now, Sixpoint can focus on their smaller, more unique brews and expand the breadth of their beer selection.

Smuttynose Pumpkin Ale
Where you think it’s brewed: Portsmouth, NH
Where it’s brewed: F.X. Matt Brewery, Utica, NY
For the first time in Smuttynose’s history, one of their beers is being brewed outside of the confines of their Portsmouth, New Hampshire brewery. Pumpkin Ale is Smuttynose’s most popular seasonal beer, and contracting the brewing to F.X. Matt helped them meet the demand at the very beginning of the season, instead of having the beer trickle through supply chains throughout the fall. This means there’s no need to go on a wild goose chase to hunt down this delicious fall seasonal this year.

